Business Interruption Insurance

Suzette Araneta

Have you made a claim on your business insurance due to the Covid-19 pandemic?

Cloth-made open and close signboard stating

There has been much uncertainty surrounding the extent to which businesses affected by the Covid-19 Pandemic can rely on their Business Interruption Insurance for COVID-19 related losses. 

To resolve uncertainty, the Insurance Council of Australia (ICA) took the first business interruption insurance case in Australia to the court to clarify that its members’ policies did not cover pandemics. 

The Insurers lost the case and sought to appeal the decision in the High Court which was subsequently denied by the High Court on 25 June 2021. 


The Test Case 

- 4 Policyholders were insured against Business Interruption Insurance under two different Insurance Policies and sought to make a claim for Business Interruption Insurance for loses resulting from the COID-19 pandemic.

- both policies referred to the now outdated Quarantine Act 1908 (Cth) (replaced by the Biosecurity Act 2015 (Cth)) which contained the following exclusion clause:


“The cover… does not apply to any circumstances involving ‘highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza in Humans’ or other diseases declared to be quarantinable diseases under the Australian Quarantine Act 1908 and subsequent amendments” 


- The Insurers argued that the wording of the exclusion clause extended to diseases determined to be “listed human diseases” under the Biosecurity Act either because the Biosecurity Act was a “subsequent amendment” to the Quarantine Act or because references to the Quarantine Act were obvious mistakes and that it was clear the Insurers had intended to refer to the replacement Act.

- The New South Wales Supreme Court of Appeal rejected the Insurers’ argument on the basis that COVID-19 is not a diseased declared to be a quarantinable disease under the Quarantine Act and therefore the exclusion clause was not enlivened.

- The Court also rejected the Insurers’ argument that reference to the Quarantine Act was a mistake which can be corrected when construing the Contract.


What this Means for your Business 

This landmark decision, although limited to specific policy wording, means that insurers cannot now rely on references to the Quarantine Act to deny liability in policies written in the same terms as the policies referred to in this test case. Insurers have now commenced proceedings in a second test case in the Federal Court of Australia to determine the meaning of policy wordings such as the definition of diseases, proximity of outbreak to a business and prevention of access to business premises due to a government mandate. 


If your claim has previously been denied or if you have held off in making a claim because of the same exclusion in your policy (or similar), please contact Suzette Araneta on 1300 249 299 to find out how we can assist you. 


Contact Us Now!

For comprehensive legal services, 
book now for your free initial consultation.

Contact Us

Book Now!

Property & Conveyancing
Guarantor  Advice
Commercial & Business
Wills and Estates
Building Disputes
Employment Law
Corporate & Commercial 
Litigation
Regulatory Compliance
Immigration
Litigation
Insolvency & Bankruptcy

Contact Us Now!

For comprehensive legal services, 
book now for your free initial consultation.

Contact Us

Book Us Now!

Property & Conveyancing
Guarantor  Advice
Commercial & Business
Wills and Estates
Building Disputes
Employment Law
Corporate & Commercial 
Litigation
Regulatory Compliance
Retail & commercial leasing, business transactions, company & trust sales, property development, guarantor advice

Our Latest Story

By November 2026 Edition • 5 November 2026
Whether you are preparing for Black Friday, launching an online store or selling online year-round, increased traffic and orders can expose gaps in your terms, pricing, delivery promises and returns processes. If these are unclear or inconsistent with Australian Consumer Law, your business may face complaints, chargebacks and disputes. The following areas provide a practical starting point for checking that customers can clearly understand what they are buying, the total cost, expected delivery and what happens if something goes wrong. Are Your Online Terms Clear and Easy to Find? Online terms should be available before purchase, written in plain English and clearly accepted, such as through a checkout checkbox. They should identify the seller and address orders, payments, stock, cancellations and liability without removing customers’ Australian Consumer Law rights. The appropriate wording will depend on the business’s products, sales process and risks. Are Your Discounts and Price Claims Accurate? Discount claims – including Black Friday promotions, percentage savings, “was/now” pricing, countdowns and limited-stock messages, must be accurate and supportable. New businesses should not claim a previous price unless the product was genuinely offered at that amount, while established retailers should ensure their pricing history supports the saving. Mandatory fees must be included in the total, with other charges disclosed before checkout. Do Your Returns Terms Respect Consumer Guarantees? Discounted goods generally carry the same consumer guarantee rights as full-price goods, so statements such as “no refunds on sale items” cannot exclude remedies for faulty, unsafe or misdescribed products. Returns policies should distinguish these rights from change-of-mind returns and explain how customers can request a remedy without misleading limits or conditions. Can You Meet Your Delivery and Stock Promises? High order volumes can place pressure on stock and delivery systems. Website information and fulfilment terms should use realistic estimates and reflect how the business handles delays, unavailable stock, pre-orders and damaged parcels. The appropriate approach depends on the products, delivery providers and promises made to customers. Could Any of Your Terms Be Unfair? Standard terms should not give the business broad rights while leaving customers with few protections. Clauses allowing the seller to change prices, cancel orders, substitute products or avoid responsibility without a reasonable basis may be unfair. Whether a term is fair depends on its wording, the business’s legitimate interests, its effect on the customer and the contract as a whole. Are Customer Information and Marketing Consents Handled Properly? Online sales and promotional campaigns may involve email sign-ups, abandoned-cart messages, website tracking and customer information. Businesses should check whether the Privacy Act applies and ensure relevant privacy policies explain how information is collected, used, disclosed and protected. Marketing messages, including Black Friday campaigns, must also meet applicable consent and unsubscribe requirements. What Should You Review Before the Sale Goes Live? Before launching a store or major campaign, test the customer journey from advertising to post-sale support. Ensure promotional claims, product pages, prices, stock and delivery information are accurate, and that terms, policies, communications and business processes are consistent. A legal review can identify gaps that may not be obvious internally. These issues are a starting point, not a compliance assessment. Required terms and policies depend on the business model, products, customers, sales channels and campaign promises. Tailored advice can identify the obligations and risks that apply. How CJM Lawyers Can Help CJM Lawyers can prepare ecommerce terms, returns and refund policies, privacy policies and promotional terms for new stores or review the current policies for established businesses. We also advise on Australian Consumer Law, unfair contract terms, complaints and online sales disputes. Arrange a legal health check before your next campaign to help protect your business, reduce disputes and give customers confidence to buy. Disclaimer: This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. The information may not apply to your circumstances and should not be relied on as a substitute for tailored legal advice. If you need advice, please contact CJM Lawyers to speak with one of our legal professionals.
By November 2026 Edition • 5 November 2026
Running an equine business involves legal risks as well as the day-to-day care of horses and clients. Whether you operate a riding school, agistment property, breeding program, horse training business, transport service or equestrian facility, the right agreements, safety procedures and business protections can help reduce disputes and protect the people and horses in your care. The right documents and procedures will depend on how your business operates, but the following five essentials are a practical starting point for reducing uncertainty and managing common risks. 1. Written Agreements for Your Equine Business Verbal arrangements can leave important details open to disagreement. A written agreement should clearly explain the service being provided, fees and payment terms, each party’s responsibilities, cancellation or termination rights, dispute processes and what happens if circumstances change. The terms should be tailored to the business. An agistment agreement may need to address feed, veterinary treatment, emergency authority, access, overdue fees and abandoned horses. A training, sale, lease, breeding or transport agreement will involve different risks. Templates copied from another business or downloaded online may not reflect your services, location, legal obligations or unique circumstances, limiting their ability to address your specific risks. 2. Safety Policies and Risk Procedures Horses can be unpredictable, and equine workplaces may expose workers, clients, volunteers and visitors to risks including falls, kicks, bites, vehicles, machinery and unsafe facilities. Businesses should identify hazards, assess risks, implement suitable controls and review those controls regularly. Practical records may include safety inductions, safe work procedures, incident reports, emergency plans, horse suitability assessments and rules for helmets, supervision and facility use. A waiver or acknowledgement of risk, and safety signage may support this framework, but it should not be treated as a substitute for meeting work health and safety and other legal duties. It is highly recommended for equine businesses to take out appropriate insurance cover to protect their operations. Generally, your insurer will want to review copies of your agreements and safety policies and plans. We have experience working alongside clients to ensure their safety documents are compliant with those requirements. 3. Clear Employment and Contractor Arrangements Equine businesses often engage employees, casual workers, instructors, riders, farriers and other contractors. Calling someone a contractor does not necessarily make them one – the way the arrangement works in practice also matters. Since the Closing Loopholes reforms there is a statutory “whole of the relationship” test for characterising employment. If a worker is incorrectly treated as a contractor, the business may become liable for unpaid wages, leave, superannuation and penalties. Written employment or contractor agreements should set out the role, payment, hours or deliverables, use of equipment, confidentiality, intellectual property, insurance requirements and how the arrangement may end. Businesses should also keep required employment records and review whether workplace laws, awards and workers compensation obligations apply. Having your staffing arrangements assessed early can also help identify any discrepancies and potential exposure points before a claim is made or years of back-payments become due. 4. Appropriate Insurance and Asset Arrangements Insurance should be reviewed against the activities the business actually undertakes. Depending on the operation, relevant cover may include public liability, professional indemnity, workers compensation, property, motor vehicle, care, custody and control of horses, business interruption and cover for specific events or activities. Specific insurance policies can be taken out over horses themselves, and in some circumstances, you may require your clients to hold insurance over horses in your care. An overall risk assessment of your business is useful in determining which avenue is most practical for you. Business owners should understand exclusions, disclosure obligations and any conditions attached to cover. Ownership and use of valuable horses, vehicles, equipment and facilities should also be documented, particularly where assets are personally owned, leased to the business, shared with another operator or held through a separate entity. 5. Record-Keeping, Privacy and Continuity Plans Good records can be critical when a payment, injury, horse condition or service is disputed. Keep signed agreements, invoices, attendance and staff records, horse care instructions, veterinary authorities, incident reports and important communications in a secure and organised system. Equine businesses that collect personal information should check whether privacy laws apply to them. Even if an exemption is available, personal information should be collected, stored, accessed and disposed of carefully, with these practices documented in an appropriate privacy policy and, where relevant, the business’s terms and conditions. Businesses should also have a continuity or succession plan identifying who can make urgent decisions, access records, care for horses and keep the business operating if an owner or key person is unavailable. When Should These Documents Be Reviewed? Legal documents should be reviewed when the business adds a new service, changes premises, hires staff, takes on contractors, begins holding horses for clients, purchases major assets or changes its business structure. A review may also be needed after an incident, dispute or insurance change, or when legislation affecting the business is updated. How CJM Lawyers Can Help CJM Lawyers can review how your equine business operates and prepare practical legal documents tailored to your services and risks. Our equine law services include client agreements, agistment and horse-related contracts, employment and contractor arrangements, business structures, property and asset agreements, risk documentation and dispute resolution. If your equine business relies on informal arrangements, borrowed templates or documents that no longer reflect how you operate, contact CJM Lawyers to arrange a legal review. Putting the right foundations in place now may help prevent misunderstandings, protect valuable relationships and make future issues easier to manage. Disclaimer: This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. The information may not apply to your circumstances and should not be relied on as a substitute for tailored legal advice. If you need advice, please contact CJM Lawyers to speak with one of our legal professionals.
By October 2026 Edition • 8 October 2026
Cash flow pressure, overdue tax and unpaid suppliers can build gradually, leaving company directors unsure whether the business is experiencing a temporary setback or may be insolvent. Recognising the warning signs and seeking advice early may preserve more options and help directors reduce their personal risk. A company is generally insolvent when it cannot pay its debts as and when they fall due. Financial difficulty does not always mean a business must close, but delays in seeking advice can reduce the restructuring options available, increase business losses and expose company directors to greater personal risk. Business Owner vs Company Director: What’s the Difference? A business owner is someone who owns all or part of a business, while a company director is formally appointed to manage a company and has specific legal responsibilities. In many small businesses, the owner is also a director, but this is not always the case – for example, a sole trader is a business owner but not a company director. Company directors are expected to stay informed about the company’s financial position and take action when warning signs emerge. Ignoring the problem or continuing to incur debts without a realistic ability to pay them may expose directors to serious consequences. Common Warning Signs of Insolvency Warning signs may include ongoing losses, poor cash flow, overdue tax or superannuation, suppliers being paid outside normal terms, increasing debt, difficulty collecting money owed to the business, reliance on personal funds, incomplete financial records, payment arrangements with selected creditors, demands or court documents and suppliers moving the company to cash-on-delivery terms. No single warning sign necessarily proves insolvency. However, directors should seek an immediate review of the company’s financial position when several signs occur together, debts cannot be paid on time or the company is relying on new borrowing or personal funds to meet existing obligations. What Are a Company Director’s Responsibilities? Company directors must understand the company’s operations and financial position, ensure proper records are kept and prevent the company from trading while insolvent. If insolvency is suspected, directors should investigate promptly and obtain appropriate accounting and legal advice. Directors should not rely solely on current bank balances. Cash flow forecasts, debts falling due, tax obligations, employee entitlements, available finance and the realistic recoverability of money owed to the company may all be relevant.  What Can Happen If a Company Trades While Insolvent? Continuing to incur debts while insolvent can lead to civil penalties, compensation claims and, in serious cases, criminal consequences. Directors may also face scrutiny over transactions made shortly before an external administration, including payments that unfairly favour one creditor or transfers that remove company assets for less than their true value. What Should Company Directors Do First? Company directors should bring the company’s financial records up to date, prepare a realistic cash flow forecast and identify debts that are already overdue or will shortly fall due. This information can help professional advisers assess whether the company can continue trading and which restructuring or external administration options may remain available. Directors should also avoid selectively paying creditors or transferring assets without advice, as those transactions may later be challenged. Professional advice should be sought before entering new commitments, using personal funds, granting security, selling assets or agreeing to arrangements that may affect creditors. Could the Business Be Restructured? Depending on the company’s circumstances, options may include informal negotiations with creditors, safe harbour planning, small business restructuring, voluntary administration or liquidation. The most appropriate pathway will depend on whether the underlying business is viable, the level and type of debt, available assets and the support of key stakeholders. Early advice is important because some options require careful planning and may no longer be available once the company has exhausted its cash or creditor support. How CJM Lawyers Can Help CJM Lawyers can advise company directors experiencing financial distress, assess legal risk, explain restructuring and external administration options and work alongside accountants and registered insolvency practitioners. We can also assist with creditor negotiations, statutory demands, court proceedings and disputes involving liquidators or company transactions. If your company is struggling to pay debts when they fall due, has overdue tax or superannuation, or is relying on personal funds to meet ongoing expenses, contact CJM Lawyers early. Timely advice may help clarify whether the company is insolvent, preserve restructuring options and reduce the risk of the situation becoming more difficult to manage. Disclaimer: This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. The information may not apply to your circumstances and should not be relied on as a substitute for tailored legal advice. If you need advice, please contact CJM Lawyers to speak with one of our legal professionals.
Show More

Our Latest Story

By November 2026 Edition • 5 November 2026
Whether you are preparing for Black Friday, launching an online store or selling online year-round, increased traffic and orders can expose gaps in your terms, pricing, delivery promises and returns processes. If these are unclear or inconsistent with Australian Consumer Law, your business may face complaints, chargebacks and disputes. The following areas provide a practical starting point for checking that customers can clearly understand what they are buying, the total cost, expected delivery and what happens if something goes wrong. Are Your Online Terms Clear and Easy to Find? Online terms should be available before purchase, written in plain English and clearly accepted, such as through a checkout checkbox. They should identify the seller and address orders, payments, stock, cancellations and liability without removing customers’ Australian Consumer Law rights. The appropriate wording will depend on the business’s products, sales process and risks. Are Your Discounts and Price Claims Accurate? Discount claims – including Black Friday promotions, percentage savings, “was/now” pricing, countdowns and limited-stock messages, must be accurate and supportable. New businesses should not claim a previous price unless the product was genuinely offered at that amount, while established retailers should ensure their pricing history supports the saving. Mandatory fees must be included in the total, with other charges disclosed before checkout. Do Your Returns Terms Respect Consumer Guarantees? Discounted goods generally carry the same consumer guarantee rights as full-price goods, so statements such as “no refunds on sale items” cannot exclude remedies for faulty, unsafe or misdescribed products. Returns policies should distinguish these rights from change-of-mind returns and explain how customers can request a remedy without misleading limits or conditions. Can You Meet Your Delivery and Stock Promises? High order volumes can place pressure on stock and delivery systems. Website information and fulfilment terms should use realistic estimates and reflect how the business handles delays, unavailable stock, pre-orders and damaged parcels. The appropriate approach depends on the products, delivery providers and promises made to customers. Could Any of Your Terms Be Unfair? Standard terms should not give the business broad rights while leaving customers with few protections. Clauses allowing the seller to change prices, cancel orders, substitute products or avoid responsibility without a reasonable basis may be unfair. Whether a term is fair depends on its wording, the business’s legitimate interests, its effect on the customer and the contract as a whole. Are Customer Information and Marketing Consents Handled Properly? Online sales and promotional campaigns may involve email sign-ups, abandoned-cart messages, website tracking and customer information. Businesses should check whether the Privacy Act applies and ensure relevant privacy policies explain how information is collected, used, disclosed and protected. Marketing messages, including Black Friday campaigns, must also meet applicable consent and unsubscribe requirements. What Should You Review Before the Sale Goes Live? Before launching a store or major campaign, test the customer journey from advertising to post-sale support. Ensure promotional claims, product pages, prices, stock and delivery information are accurate, and that terms, policies, communications and business processes are consistent. A legal review can identify gaps that may not be obvious internally. These issues are a starting point, not a compliance assessment. Required terms and policies depend on the business model, products, customers, sales channels and campaign promises. Tailored advice can identify the obligations and risks that apply. How CJM Lawyers Can Help CJM Lawyers can prepare ecommerce terms, returns and refund policies, privacy policies and promotional terms for new stores or review the current policies for established businesses. We also advise on Australian Consumer Law, unfair contract terms, complaints and online sales disputes. Arrange a legal health check before your next campaign to help protect your business, reduce disputes and give customers confidence to buy. Disclaimer: This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. The information may not apply to your circumstances and should not be relied on as a substitute for tailored legal advice. If you need advice, please contact CJM Lawyers to speak with one of our legal professionals.
By November 2026 Edition • 5 November 2026
Running an equine business involves legal risks as well as the day-to-day care of horses and clients. Whether you operate a riding school, agistment property, breeding program, horse training business, transport service or equestrian facility, the right agreements, safety procedures and business protections can help reduce disputes and protect the people and horses in your care. The right documents and procedures will depend on how your business operates, but the following five essentials are a practical starting point for reducing uncertainty and managing common risks. 1. Written Agreements for Your Equine Business Verbal arrangements can leave important details open to disagreement. A written agreement should clearly explain the service being provided, fees and payment terms, each party’s responsibilities, cancellation or termination rights, dispute processes and what happens if circumstances change. The terms should be tailored to the business. An agistment agreement may need to address feed, veterinary treatment, emergency authority, access, overdue fees and abandoned horses. A training, sale, lease, breeding or transport agreement will involve different risks. Templates copied from another business or downloaded online may not reflect your services, location, legal obligations or unique circumstances, limiting their ability to address your specific risks. 2. Safety Policies and Risk Procedures Horses can be unpredictable, and equine workplaces may expose workers, clients, volunteers and visitors to risks including falls, kicks, bites, vehicles, machinery and unsafe facilities. Businesses should identify hazards, assess risks, implement suitable controls and review those controls regularly. Practical records may include safety inductions, safe work procedures, incident reports, emergency plans, horse suitability assessments and rules for helmets, supervision and facility use. A waiver or acknowledgement of risk, and safety signage may support this framework, but it should not be treated as a substitute for meeting work health and safety and other legal duties. It is highly recommended for equine businesses to take out appropriate insurance cover to protect their operations. Generally, your insurer will want to review copies of your agreements and safety policies and plans. We have experience working alongside clients to ensure their safety documents are compliant with those requirements. 3. Clear Employment and Contractor Arrangements Equine businesses often engage employees, casual workers, instructors, riders, farriers and other contractors. Calling someone a contractor does not necessarily make them one – the way the arrangement works in practice also matters. Since the Closing Loopholes reforms there is a statutory “whole of the relationship” test for characterising employment. If a worker is incorrectly treated as a contractor, the business may become liable for unpaid wages, leave, superannuation and penalties. Written employment or contractor agreements should set out the role, payment, hours or deliverables, use of equipment, confidentiality, intellectual property, insurance requirements and how the arrangement may end. Businesses should also keep required employment records and review whether workplace laws, awards and workers compensation obligations apply. Having your staffing arrangements assessed early can also help identify any discrepancies and potential exposure points before a claim is made or years of back-payments become due. 4. Appropriate Insurance and Asset Arrangements Insurance should be reviewed against the activities the business actually undertakes. Depending on the operation, relevant cover may include public liability, professional indemnity, workers compensation, property, motor vehicle, care, custody and control of horses, business interruption and cover for specific events or activities. Specific insurance policies can be taken out over horses themselves, and in some circumstances, you may require your clients to hold insurance over horses in your care. An overall risk assessment of your business is useful in determining which avenue is most practical for you. Business owners should understand exclusions, disclosure obligations and any conditions attached to cover. Ownership and use of valuable horses, vehicles, equipment and facilities should also be documented, particularly where assets are personally owned, leased to the business, shared with another operator or held through a separate entity. 5. Record-Keeping, Privacy and Continuity Plans Good records can be critical when a payment, injury, horse condition or service is disputed. Keep signed agreements, invoices, attendance and staff records, horse care instructions, veterinary authorities, incident reports and important communications in a secure and organised system. Equine businesses that collect personal information should check whether privacy laws apply to them. Even if an exemption is available, personal information should be collected, stored, accessed and disposed of carefully, with these practices documented in an appropriate privacy policy and, where relevant, the business’s terms and conditions. Businesses should also have a continuity or succession plan identifying who can make urgent decisions, access records, care for horses and keep the business operating if an owner or key person is unavailable. When Should These Documents Be Reviewed? Legal documents should be reviewed when the business adds a new service, changes premises, hires staff, takes on contractors, begins holding horses for clients, purchases major assets or changes its business structure. A review may also be needed after an incident, dispute or insurance change, or when legislation affecting the business is updated. How CJM Lawyers Can Help CJM Lawyers can review how your equine business operates and prepare practical legal documents tailored to your services and risks. Our equine law services include client agreements, agistment and horse-related contracts, employment and contractor arrangements, business structures, property and asset agreements, risk documentation and dispute resolution. If your equine business relies on informal arrangements, borrowed templates or documents that no longer reflect how you operate, contact CJM Lawyers to arrange a legal review. Putting the right foundations in place now may help prevent misunderstandings, protect valuable relationships and make future issues easier to manage. Disclaimer: This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. The information may not apply to your circumstances and should not be relied on as a substitute for tailored legal advice. If you need advice, please contact CJM Lawyers to speak with one of our legal professionals.
By October 2026 Edition • 8 October 2026
Cash flow pressure, overdue tax and unpaid suppliers can build gradually, leaving company directors unsure whether the business is experiencing a temporary setback or may be insolvent. Recognising the warning signs and seeking advice early may preserve more options and help directors reduce their personal risk. A company is generally insolvent when it cannot pay its debts as and when they fall due. Financial difficulty does not always mean a business must close, but delays in seeking advice can reduce the restructuring options available, increase business losses and expose company directors to greater personal risk. Business Owner vs Company Director: What’s the Difference? A business owner is someone who owns all or part of a business, while a company director is formally appointed to manage a company and has specific legal responsibilities. In many small businesses, the owner is also a director, but this is not always the case – for example, a sole trader is a business owner but not a company director. Company directors are expected to stay informed about the company’s financial position and take action when warning signs emerge. Ignoring the problem or continuing to incur debts without a realistic ability to pay them may expose directors to serious consequences. Common Warning Signs of Insolvency Warning signs may include ongoing losses, poor cash flow, overdue tax or superannuation, suppliers being paid outside normal terms, increasing debt, difficulty collecting money owed to the business, reliance on personal funds, incomplete financial records, payment arrangements with selected creditors, demands or court documents and suppliers moving the company to cash-on-delivery terms. No single warning sign necessarily proves insolvency. However, directors should seek an immediate review of the company’s financial position when several signs occur together, debts cannot be paid on time or the company is relying on new borrowing or personal funds to meet existing obligations. What Are a Company Director’s Responsibilities? Company directors must understand the company’s operations and financial position, ensure proper records are kept and prevent the company from trading while insolvent. If insolvency is suspected, directors should investigate promptly and obtain appropriate accounting and legal advice. Directors should not rely solely on current bank balances. Cash flow forecasts, debts falling due, tax obligations, employee entitlements, available finance and the realistic recoverability of money owed to the company may all be relevant.  What Can Happen If a Company Trades While Insolvent? Continuing to incur debts while insolvent can lead to civil penalties, compensation claims and, in serious cases, criminal consequences. Directors may also face scrutiny over transactions made shortly before an external administration, including payments that unfairly favour one creditor or transfers that remove company assets for less than their true value. What Should Company Directors Do First? Company directors should bring the company’s financial records up to date, prepare a realistic cash flow forecast and identify debts that are already overdue or will shortly fall due. This information can help professional advisers assess whether the company can continue trading and which restructuring or external administration options may remain available. Directors should also avoid selectively paying creditors or transferring assets without advice, as those transactions may later be challenged. Professional advice should be sought before entering new commitments, using personal funds, granting security, selling assets or agreeing to arrangements that may affect creditors. Could the Business Be Restructured? Depending on the company’s circumstances, options may include informal negotiations with creditors, safe harbour planning, small business restructuring, voluntary administration or liquidation. The most appropriate pathway will depend on whether the underlying business is viable, the level and type of debt, available assets and the support of key stakeholders. Early advice is important because some options require careful planning and may no longer be available once the company has exhausted its cash or creditor support. How CJM Lawyers Can Help CJM Lawyers can advise company directors experiencing financial distress, assess legal risk, explain restructuring and external administration options and work alongside accountants and registered insolvency practitioners. We can also assist with creditor negotiations, statutory demands, court proceedings and disputes involving liquidators or company transactions. If your company is struggling to pay debts when they fall due, has overdue tax or superannuation, or is relying on personal funds to meet ongoing expenses, contact CJM Lawyers early. Timely advice may help clarify whether the company is insolvent, preserve restructuring options and reduce the risk of the situation becoming more difficult to manage. Disclaimer: This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. The information may not apply to your circumstances and should not be relied on as a substitute for tailored legal advice. If you need advice, please contact CJM Lawyers to speak with one of our legal professionals.
Show More

Our Latest Story

By November 2026 Edition • 5 November 2026
Whether you are preparing for Black Friday, launching an online store or selling online year-round, increased traffic and orders can expose gaps in your terms, pricing, delivery promises and returns processes. If these are unclear or inconsistent with Australian Consumer Law, your business may face complaints, chargebacks and disputes. The following areas provide a practical starting point for checking that customers can clearly understand what they are buying, the total cost, expected delivery and what happens if something goes wrong. Are Your Online Terms Clear and Easy to Find? Online terms should be available before purchase, written in plain English and clearly accepted, such as through a checkout checkbox. They should identify the seller and address orders, payments, stock, cancellations and liability without removing customers’ Australian Consumer Law rights. The appropriate wording will depend on the business’s products, sales process and risks. Are Your Discounts and Price Claims Accurate? Discount claims – including Black Friday promotions, percentage savings, “was/now” pricing, countdowns and limited-stock messages, must be accurate and supportable. New businesses should not claim a previous price unless the product was genuinely offered at that amount, while established retailers should ensure their pricing history supports the saving. Mandatory fees must be included in the total, with other charges disclosed before checkout. Do Your Returns Terms Respect Consumer Guarantees? Discounted goods generally carry the same consumer guarantee rights as full-price goods, so statements such as “no refunds on sale items” cannot exclude remedies for faulty, unsafe or misdescribed products. Returns policies should distinguish these rights from change-of-mind returns and explain how customers can request a remedy without misleading limits or conditions. Can You Meet Your Delivery and Stock Promises? High order volumes can place pressure on stock and delivery systems. Website information and fulfilment terms should use realistic estimates and reflect how the business handles delays, unavailable stock, pre-orders and damaged parcels. The appropriate approach depends on the products, delivery providers and promises made to customers. Could Any of Your Terms Be Unfair? Standard terms should not give the business broad rights while leaving customers with few protections. Clauses allowing the seller to change prices, cancel orders, substitute products or avoid responsibility without a reasonable basis may be unfair. Whether a term is fair depends on its wording, the business’s legitimate interests, its effect on the customer and the contract as a whole. Are Customer Information and Marketing Consents Handled Properly? Online sales and promotional campaigns may involve email sign-ups, abandoned-cart messages, website tracking and customer information. Businesses should check whether the Privacy Act applies and ensure relevant privacy policies explain how information is collected, used, disclosed and protected. Marketing messages, including Black Friday campaigns, must also meet applicable consent and unsubscribe requirements. What Should You Review Before the Sale Goes Live? Before launching a store or major campaign, test the customer journey from advertising to post-sale support. Ensure promotional claims, product pages, prices, stock and delivery information are accurate, and that terms, policies, communications and business processes are consistent. A legal review can identify gaps that may not be obvious internally. These issues are a starting point, not a compliance assessment. Required terms and policies depend on the business model, products, customers, sales channels and campaign promises. Tailored advice can identify the obligations and risks that apply. How CJM Lawyers Can Help CJM Lawyers can prepare ecommerce terms, returns and refund policies, privacy policies and promotional terms for new stores or review the current policies for established businesses. We also advise on Australian Consumer Law, unfair contract terms, complaints and online sales disputes. Arrange a legal health check before your next campaign to help protect your business, reduce disputes and give customers confidence to buy. Disclaimer: This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. The information may not apply to your circumstances and should not be relied on as a substitute for tailored legal advice. If you need advice, please contact CJM Lawyers to speak with one of our legal professionals.
By November 2026 Edition • 5 November 2026
Running an equine business involves legal risks as well as the day-to-day care of horses and clients. Whether you operate a riding school, agistment property, breeding program, horse training business, transport service or equestrian facility, the right agreements, safety procedures and business protections can help reduce disputes and protect the people and horses in your care. The right documents and procedures will depend on how your business operates, but the following five essentials are a practical starting point for reducing uncertainty and managing common risks. 1. Written Agreements for Your Equine Business Verbal arrangements can leave important details open to disagreement. A written agreement should clearly explain the service being provided, fees and payment terms, each party’s responsibilities, cancellation or termination rights, dispute processes and what happens if circumstances change. The terms should be tailored to the business. An agistment agreement may need to address feed, veterinary treatment, emergency authority, access, overdue fees and abandoned horses. A training, sale, lease, breeding or transport agreement will involve different risks. Templates copied from another business or downloaded online may not reflect your services, location, legal obligations or unique circumstances, limiting their ability to address your specific risks. 2. Safety Policies and Risk Procedures Horses can be unpredictable, and equine workplaces may expose workers, clients, volunteers and visitors to risks including falls, kicks, bites, vehicles, machinery and unsafe facilities. Businesses should identify hazards, assess risks, implement suitable controls and review those controls regularly. Practical records may include safety inductions, safe work procedures, incident reports, emergency plans, horse suitability assessments and rules for helmets, supervision and facility use. A waiver or acknowledgement of risk, and safety signage may support this framework, but it should not be treated as a substitute for meeting work health and safety and other legal duties. It is highly recommended for equine businesses to take out appropriate insurance cover to protect their operations. Generally, your insurer will want to review copies of your agreements and safety policies and plans. We have experience working alongside clients to ensure their safety documents are compliant with those requirements. 3. Clear Employment and Contractor Arrangements Equine businesses often engage employees, casual workers, instructors, riders, farriers and other contractors. Calling someone a contractor does not necessarily make them one – the way the arrangement works in practice also matters. Since the Closing Loopholes reforms there is a statutory “whole of the relationship” test for characterising employment. If a worker is incorrectly treated as a contractor, the business may become liable for unpaid wages, leave, superannuation and penalties. Written employment or contractor agreements should set out the role, payment, hours or deliverables, use of equipment, confidentiality, intellectual property, insurance requirements and how the arrangement may end. Businesses should also keep required employment records and review whether workplace laws, awards and workers compensation obligations apply. Having your staffing arrangements assessed early can also help identify any discrepancies and potential exposure points before a claim is made or years of back-payments become due. 4. Appropriate Insurance and Asset Arrangements Insurance should be reviewed against the activities the business actually undertakes. Depending on the operation, relevant cover may include public liability, professional indemnity, workers compensation, property, motor vehicle, care, custody and control of horses, business interruption and cover for specific events or activities. Specific insurance policies can be taken out over horses themselves, and in some circumstances, you may require your clients to hold insurance over horses in your care. An overall risk assessment of your business is useful in determining which avenue is most practical for you. Business owners should understand exclusions, disclosure obligations and any conditions attached to cover. Ownership and use of valuable horses, vehicles, equipment and facilities should also be documented, particularly where assets are personally owned, leased to the business, shared with another operator or held through a separate entity. 5. Record-Keeping, Privacy and Continuity Plans Good records can be critical when a payment, injury, horse condition or service is disputed. Keep signed agreements, invoices, attendance and staff records, horse care instructions, veterinary authorities, incident reports and important communications in a secure and organised system. Equine businesses that collect personal information should check whether privacy laws apply to them. Even if an exemption is available, personal information should be collected, stored, accessed and disposed of carefully, with these practices documented in an appropriate privacy policy and, where relevant, the business’s terms and conditions. Businesses should also have a continuity or succession plan identifying who can make urgent decisions, access records, care for horses and keep the business operating if an owner or key person is unavailable. When Should These Documents Be Reviewed? Legal documents should be reviewed when the business adds a new service, changes premises, hires staff, takes on contractors, begins holding horses for clients, purchases major assets or changes its business structure. A review may also be needed after an incident, dispute or insurance change, or when legislation affecting the business is updated. How CJM Lawyers Can Help CJM Lawyers can review how your equine business operates and prepare practical legal documents tailored to your services and risks. Our equine law services include client agreements, agistment and horse-related contracts, employment and contractor arrangements, business structures, property and asset agreements, risk documentation and dispute resolution. If your equine business relies on informal arrangements, borrowed templates or documents that no longer reflect how you operate, contact CJM Lawyers to arrange a legal review. Putting the right foundations in place now may help prevent misunderstandings, protect valuable relationships and make future issues easier to manage. Disclaimer: This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. The information may not apply to your circumstances and should not be relied on as a substitute for tailored legal advice. If you need advice, please contact CJM Lawyers to speak with one of our legal professionals.
By October 2026 Edition • 8 October 2026
Cash flow pressure, overdue tax and unpaid suppliers can build gradually, leaving company directors unsure whether the business is experiencing a temporary setback or may be insolvent. Recognising the warning signs and seeking advice early may preserve more options and help directors reduce their personal risk. A company is generally insolvent when it cannot pay its debts as and when they fall due. Financial difficulty does not always mean a business must close, but delays in seeking advice can reduce the restructuring options available, increase business losses and expose company directors to greater personal risk. Business Owner vs Company Director: What’s the Difference? A business owner is someone who owns all or part of a business, while a company director is formally appointed to manage a company and has specific legal responsibilities. In many small businesses, the owner is also a director, but this is not always the case – for example, a sole trader is a business owner but not a company director. Company directors are expected to stay informed about the company’s financial position and take action when warning signs emerge. Ignoring the problem or continuing to incur debts without a realistic ability to pay them may expose directors to serious consequences. Common Warning Signs of Insolvency Warning signs may include ongoing losses, poor cash flow, overdue tax or superannuation, suppliers being paid outside normal terms, increasing debt, difficulty collecting money owed to the business, reliance on personal funds, incomplete financial records, payment arrangements with selected creditors, demands or court documents and suppliers moving the company to cash-on-delivery terms. No single warning sign necessarily proves insolvency. However, directors should seek an immediate review of the company’s financial position when several signs occur together, debts cannot be paid on time or the company is relying on new borrowing or personal funds to meet existing obligations. What Are a Company Director’s Responsibilities? Company directors must understand the company’s operations and financial position, ensure proper records are kept and prevent the company from trading while insolvent. If insolvency is suspected, directors should investigate promptly and obtain appropriate accounting and legal advice. Directors should not rely solely on current bank balances. Cash flow forecasts, debts falling due, tax obligations, employee entitlements, available finance and the realistic recoverability of money owed to the company may all be relevant.  What Can Happen If a Company Trades While Insolvent? Continuing to incur debts while insolvent can lead to civil penalties, compensation claims and, in serious cases, criminal consequences. Directors may also face scrutiny over transactions made shortly before an external administration, including payments that unfairly favour one creditor or transfers that remove company assets for less than their true value. What Should Company Directors Do First? Company directors should bring the company’s financial records up to date, prepare a realistic cash flow forecast and identify debts that are already overdue or will shortly fall due. This information can help professional advisers assess whether the company can continue trading and which restructuring or external administration options may remain available. Directors should also avoid selectively paying creditors or transferring assets without advice, as those transactions may later be challenged. Professional advice should be sought before entering new commitments, using personal funds, granting security, selling assets or agreeing to arrangements that may affect creditors. Could the Business Be Restructured? Depending on the company’s circumstances, options may include informal negotiations with creditors, safe harbour planning, small business restructuring, voluntary administration or liquidation. The most appropriate pathway will depend on whether the underlying business is viable, the level and type of debt, available assets and the support of key stakeholders. Early advice is important because some options require careful planning and may no longer be available once the company has exhausted its cash or creditor support. How CJM Lawyers Can Help CJM Lawyers can advise company directors experiencing financial distress, assess legal risk, explain restructuring and external administration options and work alongside accountants and registered insolvency practitioners. We can also assist with creditor negotiations, statutory demands, court proceedings and disputes involving liquidators or company transactions. If your company is struggling to pay debts when they fall due, has overdue tax or superannuation, or is relying on personal funds to meet ongoing expenses, contact CJM Lawyers early. Timely advice may help clarify whether the company is insolvent, preserve restructuring options and reduce the risk of the situation becoming more difficult to manage. Disclaimer: This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. The information may not apply to your circumstances and should not be relied on as a substitute for tailored legal advice. If you need advice, please contact CJM Lawyers to speak with one of our legal professionals.
Show More

Our Client Say

Our Client Say

Our Client Say